| ITEM | SONG | FROM | ARTIST |
|---|
| 1 | All That Jazz | Chicago | Broadway Cast |
| 2 | Typically English | Stop the World I Want to Get Off | Original Broadway Cast |
| 3 | But Mr. Adams | 1776 | Broadway Cast |
| 4 | When I'm Being Born Again | On a Clear Day You Can See Forever | Original Broadway Cast |
| -break- |
| 5 | The Vigil | Snoopy the Musical | Original London Cast |
| 6 | Spiffin' Up Ziggy's | Captain Louie | Original Cast |
| 7 | Dentist! | Little Shop Of Horrors | Original Cast |
| Phone request |
| 8 | There's Gotta Be Something Better Than This | Sweet Charity | Original Broadway Cast |
| Phone request |
| 9 | This Is Halloween | The Nightmare Before Christmas | Original Movie Cast |
| -break- |
| 10 | Warriors | Lord of the Dance | Ronan Hardiman |
| -break- |
| 11 | America | West Side Story | Original Broadway Cast |
| Phone request |
| 12 | Toucha, Toucha, Touch Me | The Rocky Horror Show | Original Roxy Cast |
| Phone request |
| 13 | The Coming of the Dawn | Frankenstein | Original Broadway Cast |
| 14 | One Day More | Les Miserables | Cameron Mackintosh |
| 15 | Lichtenburg | Call Me Madam | Original Cast |
| -break- |
| 16 | Ghosts + Ghoulies + Things That Go Bump In The Night/Halloween Ballet | Meet Me In Saint Louis | Original Broadway Cast |
| 17 | Kansasland | Curtains | Original Broadway Cast |
| Request by Lynette |
| 18 | More I Cannot Wish You | Guys and Dolls | Broadway Cast |
| Phone request |
| 19 | Alone In The Universe | Seussical The Musical | Original Cast |
| 20 | Hey, Big Spender - Hey, Bob Fosse | Forbidden Broadway Volume 2 | Unoriginal Cast |
| -break- |
| 21 | Victoria's Escape | Corpse Bride | Original Movie Cast |
| -break- |
| 22 | Pretty Women - Epiphany | Sweeney Todd | Broadway Cast |
| 23 | Transylvania Mania | Young Frankenstein | Original Broadway Cast |
| 24 | We Can Do It | The Producers | Original Broadway Cast |
| Request by Lynette |
| 25 | Uptown | The Wild Party | Original Cast |
| -break- |
| 26 | The Hanging | The Crucible - Movie | George Fenton |
| -break- |
| 27 | The Phantom of the Opera | The Phantom of the Opera | Original Movie Cast |
| 28 | Trick Or Treat | Captain Louie | Original Cast |
| 29 | 76 Hit Shows | Forbidden Broadway 2001: A Spoof Odyssey | Original Cast |
| 30 | Many a New Day | Oklahoma! | Broadway Cast |
| 31 | No One Has Ever Loved Me | Passion | Original Broadway Cast |
| -break- |
| 32 | Casting a Spell | Corpse Bride | Original Movie Cast |
| -break- |
| 33 | Remains of the Day (Combo Lounge Version) | Corpse Bride | Original Movie Cast |
| -break- |
| 34 | Time Warp | The Rocky Horror Show | Original Roxy Cast |
| 35 | One Hallowe'en | Applause | Original Broadway Cast |
| 36 | Remains of the Day | Corpse Bride | Original Movie Cast |
| 37 | Mr. Mistoffolees | Cats (Disc 2) | Original Broadway Cast |
| 38 | Shadows | Captain Louie | Original Cast |
| 39 | Jack's Obession | The Nightmare Before Christmas | Original Movie Cast |
| -break- |
| 40 | Moon Dance | Corpse Bride | Original Movie Cast |
| -break- |
| 41 | Murder, Murder | Jekyll & Hyde | Original Broadway Cast |
| 42 | Come Look At The Freaks | Side Show | Original Broadway Cast |
| 43 | These Hands | Frankenstein | Original Broadway Cast |
| -break- |
| 44 | New Arrival | Corpse Bride | Original Movie Cast |
| -break- |
| 45 | Seventy-Six Trombones | The Music Man | Meredith Willson |
